Hello dear
Welcome To Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe
Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe, located in Tonawanda Town, NY, is a culinary gem specializing in authentic New York-style pizza. With a menu that boasts hand-tossed pizzas, generous portions, and a variety of flavorful Italian dishes, it promises something for everyone. Patrons rave about their customizable options and delicious subs, like the Chicken in the Grass, which exemplifies their commitment to quality and taste. The standout feature is their crispy crust and unique sauce choices, including a sweet option that adds a delightful twist. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere make Molinara's a must-visit for pizza lovers.
About
Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe
Welcome to Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe, a delightful culinary gem located at 2776 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda Town, NY. This charming eatery has been winning over the hearts—and taste buds—of locals with its delicious hand-tossed New York-style pizzas and an array of traditional Italian dishes.
Step inside and you'll immediately notice the warm and friendly atmosphere. With a menu boasting generous portions, the pizza experience here is truly a feast. As one enthusiastic customer, Courtney Piniewski, noted after trying the Chicken in the Grass sub, "it was ready in 10 minutes and was cheap," proving that great flavor doesn't have to come at a high price. The sub was described as perfectly cooked and loaded with ingredients, setting the stage for the quality you can expect across the entire menu.
Molinara's is particularly known for their jumbo-sized pizzas which start at a formidable 14 inches. This ample size serves not just one, but a whole group, making it ideal for gatherings. Customer Kapil Sukhija lauded the excellent preparation and generous toppings, saying, "Every time I have tried an American pizza, I am amazed by their jumbo size." The abundant cheese and fresh vegetables elevate the dining experience, reflecting Molinara's commitment to quality.
For those craving variety, the menu goes well beyond pizza. Ryan Eddy highlighted the restaurant's large, meaty wings and traditional Italian dishes made from fresh ingredients. The ability to customize orders means every guest can find a dish that suits their palate perfectly. Whether you prefer a classic marinara or something sweeter—respected by Chester Nance—the sauce selections are unique and enhance the pizza experience.
Finally, let's not forget about the crispy crust that offers a satisfying crunch with every bite, a beloved trait amongst visitors. The commitment to authenticity is evident, with reviews suggesting that they strike the right balance between traditional flavors and personal twists. If you're looking for an inviting spot in Tonawanda to enjoy hearty dishes at reasonable prices, Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe is waiting to serve you.
For a delicious meal that's made with care and attention to detail, don't hesitate to give them a call at +1 716-446-9026 and place your order today!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Ordered a Chicken in the Grass sub. It was ready in 10 minutes and was cheap. The flavor was fantastic. They didn't skimp on ingredients. Sub cooked to perfection. Will definitely order again and try something new. ”
“ Every time I have tried an American pizza, I am amazed by their jumbo size. Even a small pizza is 14" which is good enough for 4 people. Talking about this restaurant, I really enjoyed their preparation. The pizza we ordered was worth it's price given the quantum of cheese and the veggies stuffed on them. Service is good and the owner is friendly. ”
“ They offer delicious hand-tossed NY style pizzas and large meaty wings. They also have plenty of traditional Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients alongside plenty of choices for subs. Every menu item is made to your preference, with customers being able to customize their orders. I highly recommend. ”
“ The pizza was very good. It is interesting that they offer three different sauces sweet, sweet mixed with a more traditional one and traditional. I like the crispy crust on it. ”
“ Best authentic in my opinion, even offer sweet pizza sauce. ”
“ Ordered a large cheese and pepperoni with “semi-sweet” sauce. Pizza was cooked pretty well. Chup n char was good. It was like an nyc style that was a tad thicker. Had some flop. Good sauce. I’m a sweet sauce fan so I will try sweet sauce next time. Plenty of cheese. Crust was good A good Buffalo pizza Thank you ”
“ We just started ordering food from there this year and their New York style pizza is some of the best I've ever had! The wings are excellent, done to crispy perfection! I had a Philly Cheese steak and it was TOP NOTCH. Friendly and prompt service.... ”
“ Definitely try the sweet thin crust pizza!! All their pizza is so good. They have some yummy treats as well, don't pass them up! We travel from Hilton as a special treat for a pie or two...been going there since before we moved out of the area. The people serving at tables or for a to go order are always pleasant and happy to see you. There's plenty of parking too. ”